VW OBD II Revisited: Good Vehicle Service History Helps Determine Causes of Repeat Failures – UnderhoodService

VW OBD II Revisited: Good Vehicle Service History Helps Determine Causes of Repeat Failures

After 10-plus years of dealing with OBD II, it should be apparent that we are on a learning curve that probably has no end. Almost daily we have a VAG model come into the shop with a check engine light on, or a “state OBD II failure” form. Although we have the latest scanner software packages, some of these failures can still be elusive to resolve.

In this article, I’ll revisit some of the more common failures that we continue to see and how we resolved them, saving you time and cost for your customer. As always, throwing parts at a problem is not the best tool for OBD repairs. Knowing how a component is designed to work is always the first step in locating a failure.

Whatever the reason for the MIL to be on, there was a sequence of events that lead the ECM to conclude there was a problem. A visual inspection should always be the first step in any diagnostic procedure. After pulling codes in the case of an OBD failure, a look at the system involved just might turn up an obvious fault without any test equipment.

The most important element of VW OBD II repair is having the right equipment. You need to not only pull codes, but be able to track data and perform at least basic activations to test systems’ operation. To make repairs, you will need to locate the cause before replacing parts. As the parameters for components get narrower, the need for more accurate data becomes paramount. When choosing from among the number of scanners available on the market, make sure whatever you get is upgradeable.

While on the subject of scanners, be sure to protect yourself and your equipment. Purchase a small VAG tester – a little tool that works on virtually any vehicle and should be used before connecting to any OBD II car with aftermarket equipment installed. We’ve seen many cases where shortly after the installation of a stereo, phone or other equipment, communication was lost with the ECU. With improper attachment to OBD wiring, a backfeed from that equipment can not only take out the car’s computer, but your scanner as well. If you use one of these testers, a red indicator can save time and make you money.

With VAG cars, having a scanner with the capability to pull codes and data from earlier OBD I cars can also add to your bottom line. With the twin-lead (white and black) adaptor, you can access codes on some models that are nearly 20 years old.

A DVOM or graphing multimeter will also be a great help in diagnosis. We often have more than one meter set up on a single component to watch both input and output data when tracing difficult faults. Most of the test procedures for resolving OBD faults on VWs involve the use of a test box or breakout box. With a good wiring diagram and the proper probes, the tests can be performed without the box, at the component or at the ECM. We very often have to search several databases or contact tech support for the specific information we need to test individual components for proper input and output parameters.

In the following parts of this article, I’ll cover some of the most common OBD codes we see. They are the codes that come up on a regular basis, and the symptoms and sequence that caused the failure are often the same. Having a good service history on a particular car often helps in determining the cause of some failures. Driving habits often can lead to repeat failures. Don’t be fooled by a car that is still running OK even with the light on. VW has done a great job of making its vehicles still run pretty well, even in “limp mode.”

First a short review of basic DTC makeup. P codes relate to Powertrain control malfunctions. DTCs that start with P0 are federally mandated control parameters, and should be accessible with any scanner, but may provide only basic interpretation and not be much help other than pointing in a general direction for diagnosis.

DTCs starting with P1 are manufacturer-specific codes that may not always be interpreted by a generic scanner. From there, the numbers narrow the scope of the DTC to a particular control parameter, and then a specific component. VAG cars can also have five-number, VW-specific DTCs that have no OBD II match. This is why having a scanner that can access VW-specific information can be a time saver if you work on many of these vehicles.

DTC P0116, 117, 118, 125 – Engine Coolant Temp Sensor (ECT) out of range
This set of codes is almost always accompanied by a report of overheating. The most common cause is water pump failure (see Photo 1). Start by looking for obvious coolant leaks, low coolant level or other signs of overheating. Certainly check the ECT for resistance values; replace if it’s out of specification. If the coolant level is low, determine the source of leakage (see Photo 2) and repair. If there are symptoms of high engine heat when driving, but the temperature is OK at idle, the most likely candidate is the water pump.

DTC P0120, 121, 122, 221, 507 and more – Throttle Control Module faults Probably the most common cause of these faults is tampering. For most VW models after 1996, the throttle angle is controlled electronically. The cable going to the throttle body is for cruise control, not throttle operation. Throttle angle is calculated by the ECM reading the angle at the pedal position sensor, vehicle speed, gear position and other factors. Simply opening the throttle by hand under the hood with the engine running can cause codes to set. Most often, the cause is an attempt to change idle speed by changing the base setting of the throttle plate, either by adjusting the stop screw or adding a shim to hold the cable linkage from closing (see Photo 3).

After determining the extent of the tampering, you will need to perform a throttle valve control module (TVCM) adaption procedure to synchronize the throttle to the pedal position sensor. Many models do this automatically if the key is turned on without starting for 10 seconds. Cars with automatic transmissions also need to have the transmission control module basic setting procedure done any time the throttle control module is adapted.

If the TVCM adaption cannot be completed after several attempts, and a thorough cleaning of the throttle body, the only solution may involve replacement of the throttle control module – an expensive part. The factory adjustments could probably be repeated, if all you have is a lot of free time. Make sure all other basics, such as vacuum leaks and mechanical faults that could have caused the tampering attempt, are resolved before taking this step.

DTC P0300, 301, 302, etc. – Misfire detection Stop! Before you even open the hood, check the fuel gauge. Is the gauge at E or F? Was the car recently run low on fuel, and then filled before being brought into the shop? These faults can be set due to low fuel level; another code (P1250) may also be set whenever there is less than two gallons of fuel in the tank.

If those symptoms are not the case, or the customer won’t admit to being at fault, go under the hood. Pull a spark plug, inspect its condition and evidence of fouling. There are many possibilities for misfire problems but, in many cases, lack of maintenance is the main cause. We get too many of these cars into our shop, after someone has changed injectors, coils, ECMs or made major mechanical repairs, only to find that a cracked distributor cap, serious carbon tracks or the wrong spark plugs were the cause of the MIL illumination. With OBD II, usually there will be specific codes for major component failures, like injectors.

DTC P0411 – Secondary Air Injection System incorrect flow detected This code comes up almost daily. The typical cause is the failure of the vacuum hose to the check valve (combi-valve) on the exhaust manifold. Just like EGR vacuum hoses have cracked and fallen off for years, this hose lives in a harsh environment not meant for rubber hose covered with cloth.

Here’s the diagnostic procedure for this code.

  1. Start the cold engine and listen for the “vacuum cleaner” sound of the secondary air pump. The pump should run for up to 100 seconds during any cold start, and may run even after a warm start or after an extended idle.

  2. If the pump runs, isn’t too noisy and shuts off after a couple of minutes, start tracing the hoses from and to the pump, and locate the check valve.

  3. Inspect the small hose to the valve. Just touching it at the valve connection will usually verify the failure (the valve may be a little warm!).

  4. If the hose has failed, replace it, preferably with a silicone hose of the correct size to prevent leakage and repeat failure.

  5. With your scanner set to activations, run the pump relay, pump and control valve tests. Use a vacuum pump to make sure the check valve is not damaged (stuck open or closed).

  6. If the pump is excessively noisy (experience is the best determining factor; they all make some noise), inspect the inlet hose for any signs of water entry. This is especially troublesome on models that have the pump mounted low in the engine compartment and draw air from the air cleaner. Like a vacuum cleaner, water getting into the pump will kill it in short order. The pump can also be damaged by exhaust getting past a stuck check valve. Always determine the cause of the pump failure before replacement, so the new pump isn’t immediately damaged.

DTC P0440, 441, 1410, 1425, 1426 – EVAP faults This is an obvious one for all cars. The first step is to always go to the fuel filler and check for a missing or incorrectly installed cap. It’s amazing to me that there are people who still don’t know about making the cap “click” when installing. A cap tester should be used next whenever there is not an obvious “operator error.” At this point, probably more than 90% of EVAP faults should be resolved.

The next step with VAG cars is to get the scanner out and test operation of the canister purge valve (see Photo 4) through the activation function. This valve is usually buried in the passenger side of the engine compartment, so this is the easiest way to check to see if it works. If the valve is working, clear the code and take the car on a test drive; if the code doesn’t reset, you’re finished. If it does reset, there may still be a leak, so get your smoke machine out and start pumping the system full of smoke and repair any leaks as needed. The place to look on most models up to 1999 is the collection of hoses near the passenger side of the engine compartment. These hoses are often not clipped into place and rub through on the accessory belt.

DTC P1127, 1128, 1137 – HO2 Sensor, Upstream TWC, long-term fuel trim faults Check tune-up basics first and for lack of maintenance. A plugged air filter, secondary air system problems or a bad MAF sensor can also cause these codes to set. This is one case where other components may cause the MIL to come on without setting a hard fault.

VW has had some problems with O2 and MAF sensors on some models, and replacements are often priced low enough to replace them as a maintenance upgrade for problem cars. Standard tests for operation of up- and downstream O2 sensors should indicate a problem and solution. If the O2 sensors seem to be operating correctly, replacing the MAF, even if there is no specific code, may be the solution.

VW ends all of its diagnostic and repair procedures with a “Test Drive Re-learn Procedure.” This can be accomplished in several ways. You can use your scanner, from a cold start and go through a step-by-step process to set basic settings, readiness codes and then check for any recurring codes. You can also take the car on a road trip, completing a designated drive cycle, and then recheck for codes. Or you can return the car to the customer with this advice: The car will need to be driven from a cold start for a minimum of 1 hour, or 50 miles, varying the speed and throttle angle, without turning off the ignition.

My procedure is to perform the basic setting procedure for the specific model and engine code, road test and recheck for codes. Return the car to the customer with the recommendation to take a road trip of at least 50 miles from a cold start. This procedure should reset all of the readiness monitors. Even the Washington State Emissions Department recommends that after an OBD II failure, a car should not return to the inspection station for a retest until it has been driven for awhile, usually a couple of days. They will not retest a car with more than one readiness flag not completed.

As emissions regulations continue to tighten, education and hands-on experience will be the factors that make or break our ability to perform repairs that will ensure a clean environment for our children. Learning to correctly repair emissions problems, and then educating our customers to maintain and service their vehicles, should be the focus of everyone in our industry.

You May Also Like

Alternator Testing For No Charge Conditions

Many alternator problems turn out to be nothing more than a bad connection at the alternator or a bad wiring harness.

If only battery voltage is present at the battery on a running engine, does this mean the alternator is “bad?” No, it does not. It only means that the alternator is not charging, but does not reveal why. Therefore, it does not point to a faulty alternator. All too often, the alternator is condemned by technicians due to this test alone. The cause could instead be a module that distributes the power to the vehicle and regulates the alternator.

Tech Tip: No Start in Cold Weather Due to No Weep Hole

This condition can be caused by condensation freezing in the muffler assembly.

Determining Catalytic Converter Efficiency

Almost every part on the engine determines how long a catalytic converter will last.

Talking To Customers About Oxygen Sensors

One of the toughest components to sell as a maintenance item, or even a replacement item, is an oxygen sensor.

PCV System DTC

PCV systems are far more complex now, but they are also much better at controlling crankcase pressure.

Other Posts

Hybrid Vehicle Fluid Maintenance

There are opportunities your shop can’t pass up just because the car or SUV has a hybrid badge on the back.

Using a Scope

Ignition coil and plug diagnostics.

Repairing Wiring Harnesses

A guide to probing and poking.

Diagnostic Procedures For Stop/Start Systems

Stop/start technology is more than just a switch wired to the brake pedal and starter.