Selling Services: Our 15 Minutes: Can A Truck Stop A Plane? – UnderhoodService

Selling Services: Our 15 Minutes: Can A Truck Stop A Plane?

Engineering and servicing brake systems has likely never been considered a “glory job.” However, it is certainly a necessary, challenging and rewarding occupation. Our contribution to driver safety and confidence can be rivaled by few others outside the medical domain.

When I first started in the brake industry, I quickly came to a point where I was underwhelmed by the glory of it. I had friends from engineering college headed off to NASA and to build planes and tanks. Some even got to go brew beer.

One day I was griping to my father about my conundrum and he made a comment that stuck with me to this day. He said, “Son there are a very few greater acts of faith in the existence of mankind than that which occurs when a person steps on a brake pedal.”

Ever since then I have been trying to find examples that would prove him wrong. Not even pulling the ripcord on a parachute wins since they virtually always have a reserve chute.

Perhaps the tape measurement that occurs on a bungy cord before you jump off a bridge would qualify. He was the first brake engineer in our family and also gave me the sage advice to “Never walk in front of the car being driven by the Brake Engineer.” Also good advice as I’ve learned over the years We in the brake industry have always had to be satisfied in our own mind that we participate in a noble profession. Because of this I have taken great pleasure recently in watching the marketing and advertising people take notice of all the wonderful things we do with our brakes.

Perhaps you’ve noticed they’ve recently made us the star of several TV commercials. I’m sure anyone with a bleeder bottle has watched the recent commercials by Ford.

The F150 rolling out of the back of the airplane and dragging that beast to a stop. I was watching TV with my 15-year-old son recently when that commercial played. He looked at me and said with all the confidence of a teenager. “Dad, that could never happen! They must have been using special effects. No way could a truck like that stop that plane.”

He got me wondering. I polled a few of my friends about whether they thought that commercial was science or science fiction. Nobody believed us brake guys could get that job done.

So in defense of all our honor, I set out to prove them wrong. No, I didn’t head out to the local airport and round up a plane, but I started by running some calculations to see what it would take. Actually the math that governs the situation is pretty straight forward. I had to make a few assumptions to get started.

  1. Weight of the airplane: 33,000 lbs. (they said this in the commercial).

  2. Length of the runway: estimated at 4,000 ft.

  3. Length of the commercial: 30 seconds.

  4. Weight of an F150: 5,800 lbs.

  5. Touchdown speed: 100 mph.

Knowing this and some simple physics, I set out to answer three basic questions to see if it could be done:

  1. Could the truck stop the plane within a 4,000-ft-runway?

  2. How long will it take to stop the plane and can I fit it into a 30-second slot?

  3. How much power do I need to absorb in the brake system?

Is 4,000 feet enough?
To answer this you must calculate how much braking (stopping) force the truck can generate. This is determined by the weight of the vehicle and the amount of traction at the tire road interface. Since it was clear it was an asphalt runway and the truck wheels were in full ABS control, it’s safe to assume that the truck is maximizing the dry road friction of the tires.

This means that the truck is capable of generating a force that is equivalent to about 1.0 g of deceleration. Therefore the truck can generate a braking force equivalent to its weight. Or said another way, I have 5,800 lbs. of force with which to stop the plane and truck. If I use 5,800 lbs. of force and apply it to a 38,800-lb. vehicle (truck + plane), I can calculate the combined mass will stop at a rate of 0.15g. Knowing this I can calculate how much runway I will need to bring the thing to a stop.

Showing the Work:
V2= Vo2 + 2as
S = (V2 – Vo2) / 2a = (100 mph * 5280/3600)2 / (2 x 4.8 ft/s2) = 2,240 feet
2,240 feet is less than the 4,000-ft. length of most runways
So there is enough Runway!!!

Is 30 Seconds enough time?
How long will it take to stop the plane and can I fit it into a 30-second slot? Using the information learned in Question 1 and another simple formula, I can easily calculate the time:

Showing the work:
V= Vo +at
t = Velocity/Acceleration -100 mph x5280/3600 / 4.8 ft/s2 = 30.55 seconds
I guess we’ll need to edit the shot!!!!

How Much Power?
The last question is how much power do I need to absorb in the brake system? Since power is by definition how much energy I need to convert in a certain amount of time, I use the following calculation.

Showing the Work
Power = Change in Energy / Change in Time Change in Energy=1/2 mv2 = 1/2 (38,800 lbs/32.2)(100 * 5280/3600)2
Change of Energy = 1.3 x 107 ft/lbs = 16929 BTU’s (770 ft/lb/ BTU)
Change of Time = 30.55 s
Power = 16929 BTU’s / 30.55 seconds = 554 BTUs
= 1994400 BTU/hr = this is the equivalent of 783 HP

Is anyone surprised that the brakes have a power capacity that is more than twice the advertised engine power? You shouldn’t be. Most vehicles would be proud to have a 0-60 mph time of less than five seconds, yet every vehicle is expected to stop from 60 mph in about three seconds. I love telling my powertrain buddies that I have way more power in my brakes than they do in their engine.

So it seems that this commercial has the potential to be a perfectly legitimate demonstration of braking capability. So next time you see it, I hope you have the same pride in being part of the brake industry that I do.

The Swing Beam Toyota commercial is a gimmick. The truck just has to be sure to stop short of the circle that the arm swings. Pretty much the same as if I told you to stop exactly at the Stop sign. As long as I give you enough distance anybody can do it. The second swing arm has to be timed to be sure the truck has enough time to get out of the way. Only risk is if the motor stalls.

You May Also Like

Transmission Line Replacement

Transmission fluid likes to be at a constant temperature. If it is too hot or too cold for too long, the performance can fluctuate and potentially cause damage to the transmission.

Transmission fluid likes to be at a constant temperature. If it is too hot or too cold for too long, the performance can fluctuate and potentially cause damage to the transmission.
If the fluid is at a constant temperature, it behaves in a consistent manner in terms of its friction and lubrication properties. What can help control the temperature is the transmission cooling circuit.
The path of the fluid in the transmission lines is not as much about the destination as the journey. The size and length of the transmission lines, along with the size of the cooler, controls the temperature of the fluid. Also, the size of the engine and weight of the vehicle can determine the design of the transmission fluid cooling circuit.
Another thing to consider is how a modified transmission with a larger transmission cooling circuit might do more damage than good. On modern vehicles, the cooling circuit is designed to manage the fluid temperatures during startup. If the fluid can’t warm up quickly due to the increased volume, damage to the transmission friction surfaces can occur. The same goes for a bypassed cooling circuit. Why? Because fluid that is too hot can damage friction surfaces.

VIDEO: AAPEX 2016 Insights

Andrew Markel discusses his take on conversations he had with economists at AAPEX 2016, including the future of purchasing parts.

BMW Tech Tip: Oil Separator Replacement

A clogged oil separator valve is a common problem on many BMW DOHC inline sixes. The high failure rate is caused by sludge build-up that can result in oil burning, rough idle and engine fault codes. Although the solution is pretty simple, replacing the valve is labor intensive and can take anywhere from six to nine hours.

New IDUSA Premium Guard Website Offers Easy Access To Wide Range Of Oil, Air, Cabin, Fuel And Transmission Filters

The new website’s bi-lingual, responsive design features look-up powered by ShowMeTheParts.

VIDEO: How To Deal With Air Conditioning Smells

Andrew Markel discusses what to do to get rid of A/C smells after customers have tried to do it themselves.

Other Posts

Spray Now or Pay Later

Time measures the profitability of both a shop and technician, and experience is the best tool for profitability and productivity. The more you work on cars and trucks for a living, the more realize that some things might cost you pennies, but not using it can cost you dollars—this is certainly the case with WD-40

VIDEO: Brake Pads Deconstructed

Brake pads are thoroughly developed to produce the best result. This video is sponsored by ZF Aftermarket.

ChrisFix Talks FMSI And New Z Numbers

ChrisFix, the world’s largest automotive DIY YouTuber with more than 7 million global subscribers, enjoys helping car owners with the nuts and bolts of automotive ownership and repair.  In his latest video, ChrisFix offers some good news from the Friction Materials Standards Institute (FMSI), which maintains the standardized part numbering system for aftermarket brake pads.

Oil Bath Air Filters

Long before people started using cotton gauze air filters soaked in oil, the oil bath air filter was the dominant filter on the market. The filter removes debris in the air by running it over oil and a mesh element. These filters worked great when most roads were dirt, but they could be messy to clean.