Mitch Schneider: Too Good to be True – UnderhoodService

Mitch Schneider: Too Good to be True

I know you should never start a piece with a lead sentence like this, but it was a "dark and stormy night" in the nightmare that abbreviated a restless evening's sleep just a few hours ago. It was really dark, and it was really stormy, and I was at the rudder of a small, leaky boat adrift in a sea of consumers, customers and clients. The ocean was rough and water was coming over the sides faster than I could ....

By Mitch Schneider
Contributing Editor

    I know you should never start a piece with a lead sentence like this, but it was a “dark and stormy night” in the nightmare that abbreviated a restless evening’s sleep just a few hours ago. It was really dark, and it was really stormy, and I was at the rudder of a small, leaky boat adrift in a sea of consumers, customers and clients. The ocean was rough and water was coming over the sides faster than I could bail it out.

It was about the time I realized I wasn’t alone that I realized exactly how much trouble I was in. Even though I knew the people in the boat with me, even though I’d known and trusted them for years, it soon became apparent they were indiscriminately pulling people into the boat no matter how low in the water we found ourselves. No one seemed to know who to pull into the boat and who to push back into the churning waters.

I tried to pilot us out of the squall, away from the chaos and toward calmer waters. But, the harder I tried, the more difficult it became. And, then suddenly, I found myself awake, disoriented and wondering what could have precipitated such a horrible dream.

It started innocently enough with a call from one of our favorite clients. It’s a family you’ve worked for in the past: great parents, great kids and a fleet of vehicles that are continuously and meticulously maintained. They have come to believe what you and I already know: a well-maintained vehicle costs less to own and operate, lasts longer and doesn’t break down unexpectedly. It’s a family that has always trusted us…at least, until now. And, that’s where the seeds of my nightmare found fertile ground.

It started with a concerned phone call about their son’s 2006 Ford Mustang. The vehicle only has a bit more than 22,000 miles on it, but they are “canyon” miles. And, that is probably what led to the call. The clutch was acting up and, under the impression it would be covered under the vehicle’s “Bumper-to-Bumper” warranty, they took it to the dealership only to find out that it wasn’t a covered item. They were subsequently given a quote to replace the clutch and now they were calling us to see what it would cost for us to perform that service. They were certain we would be less, and frankly, so was I.

Before I could ask if they were given a “firm” quote for the job, the information was volunteered: $600. And, the conversation that followed went something like this:

Us: “Was that for the parts or was it for the labor?”

Customer: “It was for everything…”

Us: “Are you sure? It sounds like a quote for about half the job on that particular model. Are you certain they indicated they were going to remove the transmission, replace or resurface the flywheel and replace all the clutch components: the disc, cover, release bearing and the pilot, all for just $600?

“Are they giving you some kind of a “Customer Goodwill” discount or something like that, because, quite frankly, that sounds unreasonably inexpensive for that service at any facility, anywhere!”

Customer: “Nope…No warranty or allowance. Just $600, and that’s it!”

Us: “OK, let us put together an estimate for you and, in the meantime, give them a call just to make sure there was no misunderstanding and the quote wasn’t for just the labor or just the parts so there are no surprises when you go to pick the vehicle up if you let them do the job. We’ll call back as soon as we get the quote together and that should give you a few minutes to double-check with the service advisor at the dealership…”

We got off the phone and I took a deep breathe. This was not going to be good. You’ve probably already started estimating that job in your head. I had already started estimating it in mine. Replacing a clutch on just about any late-model vehicle is well over $600 these days, no matter what it is or who built it!

Regardless, we sharpened our pencils and forged ahead. No matter what we did, we weren’t going to be able to deliver that service with the quality of parts and labor we insist upon for less than twice what we were told our customer had been quoted by the dealer.

I structured the sentence that way for a reason. Why? Because, despite the fact that our customer called the dealer back and had been assured there was no mistake: the clutch replacement would be “$600…and not a penny more: Period!” You’ve probably already realized that no matter what anyone had been told, this particular vehicle was not going to be delivered at the quoted price…and we shared that concern with our customer.

They decided to leave the vehicle at the dealership for the clutch and we decided to just shake our heads and wait until the next time they were in to find out what actually happened. We didn’t have to wait long! The call came two days later and the customer was distraught.

When she went to pick up the Mustang, the cashier presented her with an invoice that was just under $1,500 — more than $200 more than we had quoted her and not quite three times what she was sure she had been quoted. When she asked why it was so high, she was told that’s what she had been quoted. When she insisted she had been quoted $600, she was told that she must have misunderstood, the $600 was just for the labor, not for labor, parts, incidentals and tax. After a day-and-a-half of arguing, she finally picked up the vehicle and left the dealership $1,300 “lighter.”

There are lots of different ways to look at his event. You can look at it as a “Glass half full…” or a “Glass half empty…” thing, or you can look at it as an “All customers are whores…” or “All customers are naÏve…” kind of thing. I only see it one way: we lost a $1,300 or $1,400 job because a reasonable, rational, full-functioning adult wanted to believe the Tooth Fairy is still on the job.

They wanted to believe — no, they insisted on believing — that something that sounded too good to be true, was, in fact, going to be true, even after they’d been warned. It’s just plain foolish!

Every time something like this happens, I find myself sadly disappointed. I’m disappointed in myself for not being able to protect my customers, especially the ones I care most about, from themselves or from someone else, and disappointed in them for being so damned greedy!

I know that might sound harsh, but I’m not sure there is a better word to describe what drives the kind of behavior we had just experienced. Not in a week that saw two customers do pretty much the same thing (you’ll get to read about that next month or the month after!) with just about the same results.

You can call it lots of things…and, you could probably get away with most of them as long as there was no warning. But, this family had been warned and when you’ve been warned, you lose the ability to push the blame off on someone or something else. Once you’ve been made aware of the danger or the realities you are likely to confront and then make a conscious decision to ignore the warnings, you are pretty much on your own!

There are lots of lessons here, most of them for our clients, customers and friends. The majority of them have to do with keeping things that seem too good to be true at arm’s length because most of the time, they are.

There are others, however, that are lessons you and I probably need to remind ourselves of from time to time, many of which have to do with relationships that we’d like to believe are too good to be true. My father never missed an opportunity to remind me that most customers — in fact, all but a unique few — are whores. In all honesty, he wasn’t a cynic. However, having lived through the Depression and World War II, he was a realist. What he meant was that most customers, regardless of how good or considerate or concerned we think they might be about us or our businesses, they are still likely to do what they believe is best for them, even if that belief is unrealistic at worst, and unsubstantiated at best.

I think we need to remind ourselves that if these relationships seem too good to be true from time to time it’s probably because they are. And if we’re able to do that, we aren’t likely to be disappointed. And perhaps if we limit or control the number of times or the level to which we are disappointed, we won’t be awakened in middle of the night by ghoulish apparitions trying to steal our souls — or, maybe even worse yet, our wallets!

You May Also Like

asTech’s Patented Rules Engine Now Available

asTech users, insurance carriers and their customers can be confident with the accuracy and cost of the recommended scan type.

 asTech, a Repairify company has announced the full deployment of its patented Rules Engine, which presents users with the most accurate and cost-effective diagnostic scan type for the vehicle throughout the blue printing process and repair workflow.

The new feature gives asTech customers access to the most accurate way to identify the diagnostic and calibration scan tools that read all of a car’s OEM modules correctly – versus those that don’t – down to the year, make, model, and trim. With the Rules Engine enabled, asTech users, insurance carriers and their customers can be confident with the accuracy and cost of the recommended scan type.

Standard Motor Products Announces Pro Training Power Hour

The free, live/virtual technical series presented by Standard’s professional trainers will be geared toward technicians.

MAHLE Aftermarket Expands Cylinder Head Gasket Portfolio

New part numbers for Asian and domestic models join more than 12,000 part numbers for 900,000+ applications.

Bosch Releases 212 Aftermarket Parts in 2022

The parts cover nearly 64 million vehicles in operation across North America.

Winter ASE Registration Open

Three options offered for testing and recertification.

Other Posts

Federated 50/50 Challenge Awards Over a Hundred Prizes

Federated conducted the 50/50 Challenge to recognize and thank ASE-certified automotive service professionals.

Mitchell 1, ASE Present 2022 Technician of the Future Award

Nathanial “Nate” Nie of Mission Viejo, California, was named the 2022 Mitchell 1 / National Institute for ASE Technician of the Future.

Schaeffler Group Releases Series of LuK TSBs

In conjunction with its REPXPERT service brand, Schaeffler provides technical tips and service information for LuK products.

SMP Closes the Year with 214 New Part Numbers

SMP says it is committed to providing replacement parts for hybrids and EVs through its Standard and Four Seasons brands.