Eyeball Estimates: Stop Using Percentages if You Cannot Show Your Work! – UnderhoodService

Eyeball Estimates: Stop Using Percentages if You Cannot Show Your Work!

I have been seeing a lot of estimates recently that project how much “life” is left in the brake pads. This number is often expressed as a percentage. While I do realize that it is a number most customers might be able to understand, it is misleading and often inaccurate.

The typical estimate says, “20 percent of life left”, or “20 percent of the material left.” What really troubles me is that there is no actual “work” shown on the invoice telling how many millimeters of material is actually left on the backing plate. The “percentage” is just an “eyeball estimate.” This estimate is by no means accurate, and if you asked other technicians, you would get different numbers every time.

This is scary, and this practice could get shops in trouble.

Showing Your Work
In math class we were always asked to “show our work,” so why should it be any different when we are inspecting a critical system like the brakes?

If you were to properly estimate the percentage of material worn on a brake pad, you would first have to know how much was there in the first place. This number is near impossible to find in books or on a database. Sure you could get a new set of pads for the vehicle and use that as a reference, but would you really want to keep that many pads around for just reference?

No brake pad is designed to be worn down to the backing plate. Using the backing plate as the zero point is not a good idea, and gives the customer the wrong impression.

Every vehicle has a “minimum wear specification” for the brake pads. This number is typically between two and three millimeters. At this point, caliper piston travel maybe too excessive, or the friction material attachment method may lose its effectiveness and cause the friction material to shear away from the backing plate.

Also, some pad manufacturers change the friction material formulation in the lower layers to enable the material to flow through the holes in the backing plate. This may cause the material to wear faster than the upper layers. This makes estimating the last 20 percent of the material’s life impossible.

The Right Way
The right way to communicate to a customer if their pads are in need of replacement is to use OEM minimum pad wear specs. These specifications can be found on any repair computer based information database or in a repair manual. For the most part, these specs are between two and three millimeters. But, some vehicles will have a higher specification, like on multi-piston calipers. You should always measure the pad with the most wear.

The minimum wear specification is measured from the backing plate to the lowest point of wear on the friction’s face that contacts the rotor. On some vehicles, this can be measured without disassembly.

The best tool, in my opinion, to use is a metric tapered bore gauge. This tool can be found at most automotive tool stores for less than $15.00. This ruler’s tapered width corresponds to the numbers on the side that are in millimeters. It is like measuring the gap of a spark plug.

This measurement is very credible in the eyes of the customer because you can tie it to an OEM specification.

Stop Using the Eyeball!
I love a percentage just as much as the next guy. But, “eyeballed” percentages should not be used when inspecting brakes. It is a practice that should be stopped right now!

You May Also Like

Long-Life Coolants Explained

Different types of coolants cover a range of applications from diesel to domestic, Asian and European vehicles. Each one is formulated to a specific manufacturer’s specifications to keep their engines at an optimal temperature. But, changes to the old one-size-fits-all formula has led to confusion for consumers and even some technicians.

It may be hard to believe, but antifreeze has been around since the mid-19th century and was used initially in dynamite before finding its way into the automobile. Early engine designers tried other means of cooling before antifreeze gained a foothold. It came to prominence during World War I when it was used in tanks and vehicles to prevent them from freezing in the battlefield.

VIDEO: Engine Efficiency Brings More Hoses

Andrew Markel discusses hoses and the necessity for several of them to route fluids to all parts of the vehicle due to the growing efficiency of engines. Sponsored by Dayco.

Diagnosing Intelligent Cooling Systems

The majority of cooling systems on the roads react to what is happening inside the combustion chamber. After the engine is stressed, the heat causes the thermostat to open. Increases in temperatures will also cause the cooling fans to come on. The heat carried by the coolant is the trigger for operation of the fans and thermostat.

Modern Cooling System Design: It’s Not About Temperature; It’s About Powertrain

Given the advanced state of internal combustion engine technology, some recent cooling system innovations will actually increase engine torque and fuel economy while reducing exhaust emissions. Let me simplify that idea: new cooling system technology will make engines run better and cleaner. So, let’s get on the same page by reviewing some basics.

Modern Cooling System Design: It’s Not About Temperature; It’s About Powertrain

Reading engineering papers tends to be a boring exercise, but they do give a technician like myself a new perspective on how a common automotive cooling system could actually be improved. Of course, our immediate thought is how the cooling system can keep the engine cooler. Not so, according to one paper.

Other Posts

Spray Now or Pay Later

Time measures the profitability of both a shop and technician, and experience is the best tool for profitability and productivity. The more you work on cars and trucks for a living, the more realize that some things might cost you pennies, but not using it can cost you dollars—this is certainly the case with WD-40

VIDEO: Brake Pads Deconstructed

Brake pads are thoroughly developed to produce the best result. This video is sponsored by ZF Aftermarket.

ChrisFix Talks FMSI And New Z Numbers

ChrisFix, the world’s largest automotive DIY YouTuber with more than 7 million global subscribers, enjoys helping car owners with the nuts and bolts of automotive ownership and repair.  In his latest video, ChrisFix offers some good news from the Friction Materials Standards Institute (FMSI), which maintains the standardized part numbering system for aftermarket brake pads.

HFO-1234yf: Regulations And Requirements

SAE standard J2843, for “R-1234yf (HFO-1234yf) recovery equipment for refrigerants used in mobile air conditioning systems,” establishes the minimum equipment requirements for the recovery, recycling and recharging of R-1234yf.